Practice manager in a comms cupboard doorway while an IT engineer inspects an old server with a torch

IT consultancy or managed IT: which does your firm need?

IT consultant or managed IT provider? They solve different problems. When each is right, how they are priced, and the questions to ask before you sign.

On this page

Something in your firm’s IT needs attention. Maybe the server is getting old. Maybe the same problems keep coming back. Maybe a client has sent a security questionnaire you can’t answer.

There are two obvious routes. Bring in an IT consultant to look at it, or sign up with a managed IT provider to take it on. Firms often compare the two on price. That misses the point. They solve different problems.

The short answer

A consultant is the right call when you need a decision made or a project delivered. A managed provider is the right call when you need someone to own your IT, day to day, with no end date.

If you’re not sure which problem you have, that is the first thing to find out.

When a consultant or a one-off project is right

A consultant earns their fee when the work has a clear edge:

  • A specific decision. Should the firm move off its on-site server? Is Microsoft 365 Business Premium worth the upgrade?
  • A defined project. A migration, an office move, a new phone system. Something with a start and a finish.
  • A second opinion. You have a provider, but you want an independent view of whether they’re doing the job.
  • Due diligence. A merger, an acquisition or a new partner joining with their own systems.
  • Specialist input for a capable team. Your in-house IT is solid but needs depth in one area, such as security.

In each case the value is the answer or the finished project. Once it’s delivered, the engagement ends.

When you need ongoing support instead

The signs are different. They describe a gap in ownership, not a single problem:

  • Nobody can say for certain who holds the admin accounts.
  • The same issues come back every few weeks.
  • Security depends on one person remembering to do things.
  • Staff have found their own workarounds because asking for help is slow.
  • Nobody is watching for problems out of hours.
  • The last consultant’s report is still sitting in a folder, unimplemented.

A consultant can diagnose all of these. They can’t fix them by leaving a report behind, because the problem is that no one owns the work.

The report nobody implements

This is the most common way the consultant route goes wrong. The consultant does good work. The recommendations are sound. Then the engagement ends, and the firm doesn’t have the time or the people to act on them. A year later the findings are still true, and the fee bought a document.

Before hiring a consultant, ask two questions. Who will implement the recommendations? And who will own the result after that? If the honest answer to both is “we’re not sure”, the problem you’re trying to solve is probably ownership.

How each is priced, and what you’re left owning

Consultants usually charge a day rate or a fixed fee. For an experienced IT consultant, expect around £750 a day. A typical assessment of three days on site and in your systems, plus a written report, comes to well over £2,000 before anything is implemented. At the end, you own a decision, a plan or a finished project. Anything that needs doing after that still needs someone to do it, and that is usually more days.

Managed IT is usually priced per user, per month, with security tools, monitoring and support included. What you’re buying is ongoing ownership: monitoring, patching, security, support for your staff, and someone accountable for where your IT is heading. Our current pricing is on the Managed IT page.

Put side by side, the difference is clear. Consultant days buy you an answer once. A monthly fee buys someone who keeps acting on it. Neither is automatically cheaper. The useful question is what you need to own at the end, and who is going to own it.

The middle path

You don’t have to decide blind. Many firms start with a fixed-scope piece of work, such as a review of where things stand, and decide on ongoing support once they can see the real picture. Our IT Risk and Ownership Review is built for exactly that: a fixed £295 + VAT for firms of up to 25 users (larger firms are quoted to size), credited against your first month if you move to managed or co-managed IT with us within 30 days of the findings meeting.

That’s a sensible order. It means the decision about ongoing support is based on evidence, not on a sales conversation. If what you need is senior IT leadership rather than day-to-day support, our guide to IT advisory retainers versus project-based IT leadership covers that choice.

Questions to ask either type of provider

Whether you’re talking to a consultant or a managed provider, these questions separate the good from the rest:

  1. What exactly will I have at the end of this?
  2. Who implements the recommendations, and who owns them afterwards?
  3. Who holds the admin access during the work, and after it?
  4. How do you hand over if we part ways?
  5. What happens if you’re unavailable?
  6. Would you tell us if we didn’t need you?

The last one matters most. A provider who can’t imagine a firm not needing them is selling, not advising.

Related: IT leadership for professional firms

Alan McBurney, founder of INNOSEC

Written by Alan McBurney

Founder of INNOSEC. More than 25 years designing and securing IT, now looking after professional and construction firms across Northern Ireland.

About Alan

Next step

Talk it through with us.

Fifteen minutes on how your firm runs today, what is worrying you, and whether we are the right fit. If we are not, we will say so.

Book a 15-minute call

028 9124 4324

hello@innosec.co.uk

Cookies on this site

We'd like to use analytics and advertising cookies to see which pages help and to measure our ads. Nothing is set unless you accept, and you can change your mind at any time. See our Privacy Policy and Cookie Policy.